M5U3reading学案.doc

Script of the debate
一辩：First debater
二辩：Second debater
正方：Prons
反方：Cons
对方辩友: my fellow debaters
开始陈词：Honorable judges, distinguished guests, ladies and gentlemen, today we will have a heated debate about whether we should clone human beings with the advanced technology cloning. First let’s listen to the prons’ opinion.
正方陈词: Cloning phemenon itself exists in Nature. Existance means truth.. We firmly support the idea that we can clone human beings because it is obvious that advantages are more than disadvantages if we clone human beings and we need the advanced technology urgently to cure some deadly diseases like cancer, promote the development of genetics and decrease the pain of women who can’t give birth.
反方陈词: Yes, I can’t agree with you more, cloning can definitely cure some disease. We can benefit a lot from cloning. my fellow debater, But don’t you think cloning us human beings can solve all the problems? My fellow debater, you only focus on the advantages it can bring but ignor the problems it will cause. More over, we can never imagine what problems there will be. So we do believe that it is absolutely wrong to clone human beings.
Prons: In nature, there are many plants which are born with the instinct of cloning. Such as potato, rose. Besides, clone have already existed in natural animal and microbe. For example, monozygetic twins is acturally a clone. It